A Human Talks About AI And Humanity

In my adventures of studying what’s going on with AI I’ve been looking at how they were & are developed. I’ve been trying different AIs (except Musks’s). I’ve been listening to and reading everything I can find.

Good news!

There was an onslaught of AI news from the tech world and we’ve all been hit by a shock & awe campaign media frenzy that has not slowed down. I have lately been happy to see that serious, deeper thinkers are finally catching up and speaking out. They’ve had time to study and digest and now they are weighing in. Philosophers, psychologists, non-tech scientists and others are joining the discussion. I’m even hearing good things from serious politicians (the “grown ups”) about stepping in with oversight.

Humanity

This in the Guardian is brilliant: ‘There is no inevitable dystopia’: Jeanette Winterson on AI and the future of humanity. It isn’t so much about AI Safety as about what humans can DO as AI brings about changes. She begins with a warning about AI that matches my observations (which means she must be brilliant!),

“Our flawed assumptions, and our prejudices, being the material on which large language models (LLMs) are trained, are built into the very fabric of AI.”

But she is optimistic that AI could be good for us, if “our masters” make the right choices,

“There is no inevitable dystopia.” If things go wrong, it will be because of “old-fashioned thinking laid over this brand-new reality”. Specifically, “the idea of meaningless endless work being good for the soul is a 19th-century madness designed to keep people in their place. Most of what we fear about AI and jobs comes down to the political and economic choices our masters will make, just as they did in the Industrial Revolution.” She isn’t blindly optimistic. She does know that, “Yes, we are on track to mess up this chance to fundamentally change our relationship to the world of work” – but that’s because “our masters are using out-of-date, not-fit-for-purpose economic models”.

She urges an increase in study of the humanities,

Why save the humanities? One answer might be that they teach a sense of where we come from and who we are, which also feels threatened. “Massive numbers of students are going to emerge from university with degrees, and into the workforce, who are essentially illiterate,” one professor told New York magazine, responding to the first tranche of AI natives arriving in higher education. “Both in the literal sense and in the sense of being historically illiterate and having no knowledge of their own culture, much less anyone else’s.” It risked, a report from MIT claimed, being a kind of generational “cognitive surrender”.

Another is the processes by which people should be taught – reading, and being critical of what is read, and then having to write cogent defences of those critiques. Having to tussle your intuitions into an essay helps you to discover what – and how – you think, and how the ideas of others work.

[…] We need to think, she says, about “what’s reserved to us that isn’t going to be done bigger, better, faster, stronger by the machines. And that’s where higher education really comes in. The question that’s sitting on top of all these things about, ‘Why are these jobs going?’, ‘What’s happening in these courses that aren’t getting any applicants any more?’, is ‘What sort of humans will we need in the world to come? What are humans for? What are we going to do with us?’”. And that “takes us back to the idea of, well, OK, how do you develop a mind? How do you protect a mind? Because the mind is this massive, monstrous place where anything can happen.”

And for this, “a humanist education is essential. We have to centre the human here. By changing how we educate our kids from the start we can foreground creativity, play, problem-solving, thinking, because it’s fun to think, the arts because humans are naturally creative. Show me a child that doesn’t want to hear a story or do a dance or paint a picture or have an imaginary friend. This isn’t imposed and it isn’t elitism. It’s us.”

.